- Decide the scope, volume, and ranked outcomes before writing a single question.
- Send the RFP to four to six partners and make every bidder fill out the same pricing template.
- Ask who runs each decoration method, and ask for physical samples and references.
- Score non-price criteria first, then open the pricing.
- Run a paid pilot of 100 to 250 pieces before committing to a term.
Why a swag RFP is different from an ordinary one
Most requests for proposal are written to compare like with like. Three software vendors offer the same features, and you can score them side by side. Swag does not work that way. A promotional products partner is not selling one thing. It is selling a mix of products, decoration methods, artwork handling, storage, logistics, data, and service, and each of those has several ways to go wrong.
The result is that two quotes for "500 hoodies with a logo" can differ by 40 percent and both be honest. One includes a mid-weight cotton blend, embroidery with a digitizing fee waived on reorder, individual poly bags, and ground freight. The other quotes a thin blank, a heat transfer, bulk packing, and freight not included. If you compare only the unit price, you pick the second and discover the difference when the garments arrive.
A good RFP forces the comparison onto the things that matter. This guide gives you a working checklist, organized by what to ask, why to ask it, and what a good answer looks like. It suits a company buying $30,000 to $500,000 of swag a year, though a smaller buyer can use a trimmed version. You will find sample scoring weights near the end.
Before you write anything: decide what you are buying
The most common RFP failure is a vague scope. If you cannot say what the partner will do, you cannot judge who does it best. Settle five questions first.
What programs are in scope? Onboarding kits, event swag, a company store, recognition, client gifting, uniforms? Each has different requirements, and a partner strong at one may be weak at another.
What volume do you expect? Give ranges: annual spend, number of orders, typical order size, number of unique items, and number of ship to locations. Suppliers price against volume, and honest numbers produce honest quotes.
Who are the recipients and where are they? Domestic only, or international? Home addresses, offices, or event venues? A program shipping 2,000 individual parcels a year is a different business from one shipping 20 pallets.
What do you need to integrate with? HRIS, procurement, expense tools, accounting, or a company intranet. List the systems, even if the answer is none today.
What outcomes matter? Cost savings, quality, speed, sustainability, brand consistency, or reduced internal effort. Rank them. You cannot have all of them at the top, and the ranking becomes your scoring weights.
How to structure the document
A tidy RFP is shorter than most people expect. Eight to twelve pages is plenty, with a one page summary at the front. The structure that works best has six parts.
An overview of the company and the programs. A scope of work, with volumes and locations. A set of requirements, the checklist we cover below. A pricing template that every bidder must fill out, so answers are comparable. A timeline for the process. And evaluation criteria with weights, so bidders know what you care about.
Send the document to four to six partners, no more. Fewer than four gives you no real comparison. More than six buries you in reading and weakens the relationship, because suppliers invest less when they know the odds are low. Pick bidders on purpose: one or two current vendors, one or two recommended by peers, and one or two that offer something specific you want.
Capability checklist: can they actually do the work
Start with the basics. Do not assume a supplier can do something because their website lists it.
Decoration methods. Ask which methods are done in house and which are subcontracted. Screen printing, embroidery, laser engraving, digital print, heat transfer, pad printing, debossing, and foil all appear on feature lists. The question that matters is who runs the machine. In house production usually means better quality control and faster fixes. Subcontracting is not a problem if it is disclosed and managed, but it adds time and another point of failure. Our explainer on imprint methods will help you judge the answers.
Product range. Ask for the breadth across your categories: apparel, drinkware, bags, tech, stationery, awards, and packaging. A partner with a narrow catalog will push you toward what they stock. Ask specifically about the apparel brands and blank qualities available, and whether you can request a specific blank.
Premium finishes. If you want foil, embossing, spot gloss, or edge painting on printed goods, ask for samples. Our guide to premium finishes describes what each finish costs and when it is worth it.
Custom and packaging work. Can they do custom boxes, printed sleeves, inserts, and kitting? Can they design a custom product, or do they only offer catalog items?
Capacity and surge. Ask about peak season. How many days do orders slow down in the fall, and what happens to a job in progress when the shop is full? The answer reveals whether the supplier is capacity constrained.
Pricing checklist: make the numbers comparable
This is where most RFPs are won or lost, and where most are poorly written. The cure is a pricing template that every bidder must fill out the same way.
Give bidders six to ten representative items with exact specifications: a mid-weight hoodie in a named color and size run with a left chest embroidery of 8,000 stitches, a 20 ounce insulated tumbler with a one color laser engraving, a hardcover notebook with a debossed cover, a canvas tote with a two color print, a sticker pack, and so on. Ask for pricing at three quantities, such as 100, 250, and 500. Require that the price include decoration, setup, packing, and delivery to a specified address, or require each element to be shown separately.
Then ask for the rate cards behind the quotes: setup fees by method, per color charges, digitizing fees, artwork charges, rush fees by days saved, storage fees, pick and pack fees, kitting fees, and returns or restocking fees. A supplier that will not disclose its rate card is telling you something.
Ask about price protection. Will the quoted prices hold for twelve months? What triggers a change? Supplier price increases on blanks are common, and a clause that caps annual increases protects your budget. Our guide to minimums and setup fees explains the logic of price breaks and which fees are negotiable, which helps you read the answers.
Quality and compliance checklist
Quality is hard to put on a spreadsheet, but it can be tested. Three practices help.
Ask for physical samples of items you would actually order, decorated with your artwork or a similar mark. Not the supplier's showroom examples. Compare them side by side. Wash an apparel sample five times and see what happens to the print and the fabric.
Ask for the quality control process. When is the first piece inspected? What are the acceptance criteria for color match, placement, and stitching? What is the process when something is wrong, and how long does a reprint take? A good partner will have a written answer.
Ask for compliance documentation. For apparel, that means fiber content and care labels. For children's products, safety testing. For products with batteries, shipping compliance. For companies in regulated industries, ask about any restrictions on the gifts they can give to customers, which differ by sector and by country.
Ask for references. Three customers of similar size and program type, with permission to call them. Ask those references about on time delivery, error rate, and how the supplier behaved when something went wrong. That last question tells you more than any proposal.
Logistics, storage, and fulfillment checklist
If your program involves anything more than a single pallet to a single address, logistics will matter more than unit price.
Warehousing. Ask where inventory is held, how much space is available to you, what the storage fee structure is, and how long they will hold stock. Ask what happens to inventory if you leave, and how it is returned or disposed of.
Pick, pack, and ship. Ask for the price per kit, per parcel, and per pallet. Ask about carriers, tracking, delivery windows, and who handles lost or damaged shipments. Ask about international capability, including customs paperwork and landed cost estimates.
Inventory reporting. Ask whether you get live visibility of stock levels, reorder alerts, and reports by item, location, and cost center. A partner that sends a spreadsheet by email once a month is operating on a different standard from one with a live dashboard.
Lead times. Ask for standard, expedited, and emergency timelines by method. Compare them against your calendar using our piece on promo product timelines. Ask how often the supplier actually meets its stated times, and what the on time delivery rate was last quarter.
Technology and data checklist
This section is the one RFPs most often skip, and it is where a partner saves or costs you time over a multi year relationship.
Ordering. Is there an online portal for placing and reordering? Does it support approved catalogs, spend limits, and approval flows? Can multiple departments order against separate budgets while sharing the master account?
Integration. Can the partner connect to your HR system for onboarding triggers, to your procurement system for purchase orders, and to your accounting tools for invoices? Ask whether they support open data standards for inventory, pricing, and order status. We describe one such standard in our explainer on PromoStandards, and a partner that speaks it can usually connect to your systems without custom work.
Artwork and brand assets. Where do your logos and brand guidelines live? Can approved artwork be stored once and reused, with version control? Does the system prevent an unapproved logo from reaching production?
Reporting. What reports are available: spend by program, spend by department, item level sell through, shipping cost, and time to delivery? Can you export them? You will want this data for the annual budget and for measuring program results.
Security and privacy. If the partner handles employee names and home addresses, ask how that data is stored, who can see it, how long it is kept, and whether it is shared with third parties. This is personal information about your workforce, and your legal and security teams will want answers in writing.
Service model checklist
You will spend more time dealing with the people than with the products. Evaluate the service model as carefully as the catalog.
Account structure. Will you have a named account manager, a team, or a ticket queue? What is the ratio of accounts to managers? What happens when your manager is out?
Response times. Ask for committed response times for quotes, proofs, order changes, and issues. A five minute reply on the first email followed by three days of silence is a common pattern.
Proofing. How are proofs produced and approved? How many revisions are included? Does the partner supply a physical sample before a large run?
Escalation. Who do you call when an order is going wrong? Ask for a name and a phone number, not an email alias.
Strategic input. Does the partner offer recommendations on product mix, cost savings, and trends, or is it purely order taking? A partner who brings you ideas, such as consolidating items or moving a product to a different decoration method to save 20 percent, is worth more than one who simply processes tickets.
Sustainability and ethical sourcing checklist
Many companies now require some documentation on how products are made, particularly in public sector, health, and education contracts. Ask what the partner can document, not what they believe.
Ask about factory audits and codes of conduct for the factories that make the garments and goods. Ask whether they can supply fiber and material information, such as recycled content or organic cotton, with certificates. Ask about packaging: can they avoid single use plastic bags, and can they ship in right sized boxes? Ask what they do with overruns and returns.
Be careful with vague claims. Phrases like "eco friendly" and "green" are not specifications. A supplier that can name the certification, the percentage of recycled content, and the audit body is giving you something you can put in a report. One that gives you adjectives is not.
Contract terms to watch
The legal text deserves a real read. A few clauses cause most problems.
Term and exit. A three year term with a heavy early termination charge locks you in. Ask for a term of one to two years with a renewal option, and a clear exit path with inventory handover.
Pricing changes. Ask for a clause that fixes pricing for the term or caps increases to a defined percentage or index.
Minimums and exclusivity. Beware of annual spend commitments with penalties. If the partner wants exclusivity, ask for something in return, such as deeper discounts.
Quality and remedies. The contract should say what happens when an order is wrong: reprint at no cost, credit, or refund, and within what time. A vague "commercially reasonable efforts" does not help you when 400 hoodies arrive with the logo on the wrong side.
Intellectual property. Your artwork and brand assets are yours. The contract should say that the partner may use them only to fulfill your orders, and should not use them in marketing without permission.
Data. See the earlier section. Ask for a data processing addendum if employee data is involved.
Scoring the responses
When the proposals come in, resist the urge to look at price first. Score the non-price criteria, then open the pricing. This prevents a low number from coloring your view of everything else.
A set of weights that suits many mid-market buyers is the following. Capabilities and product range, 20 points. Price and total cost, 25 points. Quality, samples, and references, 20 points. Logistics and fulfillment, 10 points. Technology and reporting, 10 points. Service model, 10 points. Sustainability and compliance, 5 points. Adjust the numbers to your ranking from the first section. A company that values sustainability for regulatory reasons might give it 15 and reduce price to 20.
Have two or three people score independently, then compare. The discussion about where scores differ often reveals the real priorities better than the original brief. Keep the scoring sheet. It is also your defense if someone asks later why you chose the winner.
Run a pilot before you commit
Even with a perfect process, the actual experience of working together is unknowable until you do it. Select a finalist, or two, and run a paid pilot: a real order of moderate size, with real deadlines, shipped to real recipients.
Judge the pilot against what was promised. Did proofs arrive on time? Did the garments match the sample? Were the quantities correct? Did the tracking link work? How did they respond when a recipient reported a wrong size? A pilot of 100 to 250 pieces costs $3,000 to $10,000 and avoids a mistake that could cost ten times that over a year.
Use the pilot to negotiate. If it goes well, ask for the pilot's pricing to extend to the full contract. If it goes poorly, you have learned something cheaply.
Red flags in the responses
A few patterns should make you slow down.
A price that is far below the others without a clear reason. Either the blanks are cheaper, the decoration is different, or fees are hiding elsewhere. Ask them to explain the gap.
Refusal to provide samples or references. Anyone confident in their work will do both.
Vague lead times. "Typically a couple of weeks" is not a commitment.
No named person. If you cannot identify who will manage your account, expect to be a ticket number.
Pressure to sign fast. A "price valid for 48 hours" notice on a multi year deal is a sales tactic. Good partners are patient.
Big promises about technology that turn out to be a spreadsheet. Ask for a live demo of the portal and the reports, using sample data.
A realistic timeline
From first draft to signed contract, a thorough swag RFP takes eight to twelve weeks. Weeks one and two go to internal alignment and drafting. Week three is for distribution and bidder questions. Weeks four and five are the response window. Week six is for scoring and shortlisting. Weeks seven to nine are samples, references, and a pilot. Weeks ten and eleven are contract negotiation. Week twelve is for onboarding. Start earlier than you think you need to, especially if your current contract ends before the busy fall season.
If you are a reseller, an agency, or a distributor rather than an end user, the same checklist applies with a different emphasis on white label capability, blind shipping, and account level pricing. Our Trade Print tiers and the application page show how an account is set up for that kind of buyer.
Frequently asked
How many suppliers should receive a swag RFP?
Four to six. Fewer gives no real comparison, and more makes the review unwieldy and lowers the effort suppliers invest. Mix one or two current vendors with partners recommended by peers.
What should the pricing template include?
Six to ten specified items at three quantities, with decoration, setup, packing, and delivery shown, plus a full rate card for setup fees, rush fees, storage, pick and pack, kitting, and returns. Ask whether prices hold for twelve months.
How should we weight the evaluation criteria?
A common starting point is price and total cost 25 points, capabilities 20, quality and references 20, logistics 10, technology 10, service 10, and sustainability 5. Change the weights to match the outcomes you ranked before writing the RFP.
How long does the process take?
Eight to twelve weeks from first draft to signed contract, including a response window of about two weeks, samples and references, a pilot, and contract negotiation. Start earlier if your current contract ends before the fall rush.
Is a pilot really necessary?
It is the best protection against a mistake that grows over a year. A real order of 100 to 250 pieces with real deadlines shows how proofs, quality, tracking, and problem handling work in practice, and it gives you leverage to negotiate.
Talk to us about a program-level account
If you buy for a company, an agency, or a reseller business, we can walk through account pricing and onboarding.
Contact the team